登陆注册
37828000000022

第22章 V(2)

Again, we ought to reckon, not only the evils from which the citizens will be saved, but also the advantages which they will lose. The life which they are to lead appears to be quite impracticable. The error of Socrates must be attributed to the false notion of unity from which he starts. Unity there should be, both of the family and of the state, but in some respects only. For there is a point at which a state may attain such a degree of unity as to be no longer a state, or at which, without actually ceasing to exist, it will become an inferior state, like harmony passing into unison, or rhythm which has been reduced to a single foot. The state, as I was saying, is a plurality which should be united and made into a community by education; and it is strange that the author of a system of education which he thinks will make the state virtuous, should expect to improve his citizens by regulations of this sort, and not by philosophy or by customs and laws, like those which prevail at Sparta and Crete respecting common meals, whereby the legislator has made property common. Let us remember that we should not disregard the experience of ages; in the multitude of years these things, if they were good, would certainly not have been unknown; for almost everything has been found out, although sometimes they are not put together; in other cases men do not use the knowledge which they have.

Great light would be thrown on this subject if we could see such a form of government in the actual process of construction; for the legislator could not form a state at all without distributing and dividing its constituents into associations for common meals, and into phratries and tribes. But all this legislation ends only in forbidding agriculture to the guardians, a prohibition which the Lacedaemonians try to enforce already.

But, indeed, Socrates has not said, nor is it easy to decide, what in such a community will be the general form of the state. The citizens who are not guardians are the majority, and about them nothing has been determined: are the husbandmen, too, to have their property in common? Or is each individual to have his own? And are the wives and children to be individual or common. If, like the guardians, they are to have all things in common, what do they differ from them, or what will they gain by submitting to their government? Or, upon what principle would they submit, unless indeed the governing class adopt the ingenious policy of the Cretans, who give their slaves the same institutions as their own, but forbid them gymnastic exercises and the possession of arms. If, on the other hand, the inferior classes are to be like other cities in respect of marriage and property, what will be the form of the community? Must it not contain two states in one, each hostile to the other He makes the guardians into a mere occupying garrison, while the husbandmen and artisans and the rest are the real citizens. But if so the suits and quarrels, and all the evils which Socrates affirms to exist in other states, will exist equally among them. He says indeed that, having so good an education, the citizens will not need many laws, for example laws about the city or about the markets; but then he confines his education to the guardians. Again, he makes the husbandmen owners of the property upon condition of their paying a tribute. But in that case they are likely to be much more unmanageable and conceited than the Helots, or Penestae, or slaves in general. And whether community of wives and property be necessary for the lower equally with the higher class or not, and the questions akin to this, what will be the education, form of government, laws of the lower class, Socrates has nowhere determined: neither is it easy to discover this, nor is their character of small importance if the common life of the guardians is to be maintained.

Again, if Socrates makes the women common, and retains private property, the men will see to the fields, but who will see to the house? And who will do so if the agricultural class have both their property and their wives in common? Once more: it is absurd to argue, from the analogy of the animals, that men and women should follow the same pursuits, for animals have not to manage a household. The government, too, as constituted by Socrates, contains elements of danger; for he makes the same persons always rule. And if this is often a cause of disturbance among the meaner sort, how much more among high-spirited warriors? But that the persons whom he makes rulers must be the same is evident; for the gold which the God mingles in the souls of men is not at one time given to one, at another time to another, but always to the same: as he says, 'God mingles gold in some, and silver in others, from their very birth; but brass and iron in those who are meant to be artisans and husbandmen.' Again, he deprives the guardians even of happiness, and says that the legislator ought to make the whole state happy. But the whole cannot be happy unless most, or all, or some of its parts enjoy happiness. In this respect happiness is not like the even principle in numbers, which may exist only in the whole, but in neither of the parts; not so happiness. And if the guardians are not happy, who are? Surely not the artisans, or the common people. The Republic of which Socrates discourses has all these difficulties, and others quite as great.

同类推荐
  • 月季花谱

    月季花谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 玉箓资度早朝仪

    玉箓资度早朝仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Against Apion

    Against Apion

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Man and Wife

    Man and Wife

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 绕口令集

    绕口令集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 天刀和孤剑

    天刀和孤剑

    百年前,四教之中,万法道独占鳌头。百年后,七教并立,又有谁主宰沉浮。
  • 异世文明系统

    异世文明系统

    当穿越到‘唐宋元明清’五朝同空的时代,我能做什么呢?纨绔子弟?富贵闲人?可身为小国的皇子必须成为治世能臣或沙场名将不,这些我都想做我想要盛世繁华我想见识青莲与霞客的仗剑同游易安与东坡的把酒言欢少陵与稼轩的悲国悯世诗与词的碰撞;书与画的交织百业千工的兴盛;国家与民族的富强。
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 先婚后爱:霸道总裁冷冷爱

    先婚后爱:霸道总裁冷冷爱

    萧芷柔所期待的爱情是相遇,相爱,结婚。但是“好好守住公司,守住萧家的产业”是她唯一在意的东西。公司危机,被迫逼婚,她遇到了她这辈子都纠缠不清的暴戾总裁。“结婚吗……她定会照做,只能照做!”婚后第一面,是他车祸之后,她说,“好丑的男人。”低沉磁性,性感中带着冷硬,他说“后悔了么?”后悔吗,踏进一步,就再也没有回头路可走。沦陷的,是她,还是他
  • 殿下又调皮了

    殿下又调皮了

    洛檀,生于灭灵族,自小便是圣女出身,天生浴火之力无人能敌,虽顽皮好动,却也一直恪守本分,守护着南都。墨羽画,仙界的一朵奇葩,修为极高,生性冷淡,一心只想守护天下。那日,南都沦陷,南都圣上被杀,为保灭灵族血脉,圣上凭借最后一丝灵力,保住了洛檀的魂魄。自此,世上再无灭灵一族。百年后,翼国降世了一位公主,此时,墨羽画所在仙界,正是用人之际,公主孤身一人,前往仙界……(主要围绕女主的情感变化体现世间情怀,不喜勿喷)
  • 毁灭纪之使徒圣战

    毁灭纪之使徒圣战

    当有一天游戏当中的人物彻底站在你面前的时候,并且告诉你她来自另外一个世界,你是不是在想你一定疯了?或者是她疯了?
  • 东方家园

    东方家园

    刘子琳认为雷涛窃走了她的梦,让以后的工作和生活陷入苦闷而无法自拔,友谊场合被轻率蔑视,家园的权力与争纷错综复杂,在情与感的道路上陷入两难境地,最终不知情归何处。作品讲述了一群热血的年轻人住在家园的情感和生活方式,从繁华的都市延伸到每个人的内心世界,层层叠叠出现截然不同的社会风气。虽然他们的生活有很多与他人雷同,但人的一生或许重复又重复着别人曾经走过的路。用心去体会作品的初衷和思维,才能发觉生活的意义是什么,用行动去领悟作品的真谛和感知,才能发现生命的意义是什么。
  • 嗜血公主复仇之恋

    嗜血公主复仇之恋

    幼时她们惨遭折磨,被人虐待,误解,亲人死亡。。。。在绝望之时她们相遇,相同的的命运使他们结成死党。她们从此励志变强,成为黑道白道上的王者,无人不敬畏她们,害怕她们。她们带着复仇的心态回到了她们伤心的地方,复仇之恋拉开序幕,直到遇见四位少爷,爱情的种苗慢慢发芽。。。。但事不人愿,又或许是老天在故意捉弄她们,刚痊愈的伤口又再度裂开,她们再次怀着受伤的心理离开了这个让人悲痛的地方,发誓永不回来,她们最终。。。。
  • 深情不及

    深情不及

    若真有分离那日,你我约定若尚可做数……君莫挂我走江湖,只愿一萧一剑,踏遍天涯路;愿君身边之人是你的良人,唯我,孑然一身……
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!