登陆注册
7676100000036

第36章 Family Law 家庭法(1)

Law can never be enforced unless fear supports it.

—Sophocles (Ancient Greek dramatist)

家庭法,是指调整婚姻家庭关系的法律。家庭法是民法体系中的一项基本制度。有着基督教传统的美国家庭被认为是美国社会最基本的单位,家庭的和谐与稳定被认为是影响社会和谐与稳定的重要因素。美国的家庭法完全属于州法律的范畴,联邦政府无权在这一领域制定法律。不过,联邦宪法可以从保护公民自由权利的角度影响各州家庭法的制定和实施。从历史来看,美国的家庭法内容深受英国普通法的影响,了解英国普通法婚姻家庭关系的传统,有利于我们更好地理解美国的家庭法。

Family Law System in England and Wales

The family law system is in this article used to refer to the laws, procedures and rules governing family matters as well as the authorities, agencies and groups which participate in or influence the outcome of private disputes or social decisions involving family law. Such a view of family law may be regarded as assisting the understanding of the context in which the law works and to indicate the policy areas where improvements can be made.

The UK is made up of three jurisdictions: Scotland, Northern Ireland, and England and Wales. Each has quite different systems of family law and courts.

Types of family law

Family law encompasses divorce,adoption,wardship,child abduction and parental responsibility. It can either be public law or private law. Family law cases are heard in both County Courts and Family Proceedings Courts ( Magistrates Courts) , both of which operate under codes of Family Procedure Rules. There is also a specialist division of the High Court of Justice—the Family Division, which hears family law cases.

Court judgments not open to public scrutiny

A full analysis of the facts of any particular case heard in Court is made difficult by the“in camera”rule that prohibits any reporting of family law cases in England and Wales. The Court of Appeal, however allows the reporting of certain cases, provided the family remains anonymous. It is argued by some, including campaigners for“fathers rights”, that, although it is important to preserve the anonymity of all people involved in a case, there would be better protection against abuses if family court judgments could be published in the same anonymised fashion as Appeal Court judgments are; this is allowed in Scotland, which has different family laws. See Father and Mother Appeal CourtJudgmentfor an example of an English Appeal Courtjudgment and for some insight into what can go wrong and eventually be put right in one case. Although statistics are published about cases that pass through the courts, these in their nature cannot answer claims that abuses of the system are not identified and that there are effectively no quality controls. Those who wish to see this rule lifted claim that justice must be seen to be done, and this is not applied to family law cases. It is said, rightly or wrongly, that a rule which was put in place to respect the sensibilities of children involved in distressing circumstances may have become a cloak behind which considerable inhumanity can go unnoticed by society at large.

Lawyers vested interests

One claim is that early intervention is a far more effective approach, and thatshared residency rather than sole orders should be the presumed outcome of any agreement by consent or court order. Judicially led initiatives, having occurred in parts of Florida and elsewhere, have demonstrated that where clear guidance is provided atthe outset by the court about what the expected outcome will be, then this results in less hostility and therefore in a reduced workload for the courts. Some fathers rights campaigners claim that vested interests in the legal profession are politically operative to preserve lawyers revenue streams from this type of business. Judicial powers already exist to endeavour to ensure that continuity is maintained in relationships between children and fathers. Interim contact orders can be issued before the establishment of a routine that excludes the father from the children s lives.

Adversarial court system

The current adversarial system, existing in England and Wales, is said by some to encourage each parent to identify their fears, real or imagined, about what will affect their children now that the parents have separated. Some hold that when a parent expresses these fears about the other parent in this circumstance, even when fears are unfounded, they can nevertheless be treated as fact. Courts tend to be very particular about taking account of mothers expressed fears, and then the father has somehow to demonstrate that he presents no risk to the children, and that the advantages that he will confer on them are real.

Fathers rights proponents say that in such circumstances, the case can easily become a witch-hunt. Any aggression that the father may have manifested in the past is claimed to be treated as justification for limiting his involvement in his children s upbringing. If he is inexperienced at parenthood, perhaps due to value judgments about his background, or because this is a first child, the result may be that he is initially not trusted to provide basic care. In one case, for example, a father was restricted to visiting his child in a contact centre for six years, seeing his son for two hours a week without missing a single occasion, because of the mother s fears that he would otherwise abduct the child abroad. Even when he is able to demonstrate that he presents no risk, the mere fact of the mother expressing imagined fears can be used to argue that her fears affect the child and that the father s involvement should be restricted or eliminated.

Most fathers rights campaigners have had experiences that follow a similar pattern, and they are aiming that the law should be changed to prevent situations as theirs arising.

It is further claimed the whole idea of adversarial court cases to resolve family disputes has led to a sub-culture considered by people who have encountered it to be completely absurd. A typical outcome might involve a father who is a teacher, and therefore trusted to teach a class of children, but who is nevertheless not allowed to see his own children.

同类推荐
  • FoodinChina

    FoodinChina

    Chinaiscuisinehasevolvedintooneofthegreatcuisinesoftheworld.Formorethan5,000years,foodhasplayedanauspiciousroleinnearlyallaspectsofChinesesociety,fromhealthandmedicinetobusinessandcelebration,anditisnolessimportanttoday.
  • Chinesesculpting

    Chinesesculpting

    Emergingfromoneoftheoldestcivilizations,Chinesesculpturehasthrivedforthousandofyears.Astimemovesandcultureevolves,Chinesesculpturehasalsotakendifferentpathsindifferentregionsandcannotbeeasilycategorizedintoafewtypes.
  • 漫长的告别:THE LONG GOODBYE(英文版)

    漫长的告别:THE LONG GOODBYE(英文版)

    《漫长的告别》美国“硬汉派”侦探大师雷蒙·钱德勒代表作品,是作者的第六部长篇小说,荣获爱伦·坡小说奖,入选美国推理协会“史上百部推理小说”。日本作家村上春树曾经反复阅读并极为推崇的作品。
  • 阿米!走步!

    阿米!走步!

    本书包括阿米!走步!Ami! Chogbo!和谁先住进去 First , Move into Your New House和核!合!和!Conflict! Cooperation! Concord!内容。
  • 课外英语-七彩音符往日情怀(双语版)

    课外英语-七彩音符往日情怀(双语版)

    本书收录了世界经典英文歌曲,其中包括我心永恒、爱情故事、时不我待等多首脍炙人口的歌曲,每首歌曲都有中英文歌词、语言点解析及注释赏析。
热门推荐
  • 星球神卫

    星球神卫

    辰烨二十二岁男主蓝星第9代星球神卫。碰巧遇到无数年都没有发生过的异型入侵,作为一代神卫,这是得多倒霉,但守护蓝星,守护人类,守护爱人,为了人族的延续,为了漂亮的小姐姐们,我要誓死守卫我们的家园。
  • 纨绔狂妃别嚣张

    纨绔狂妃别嚣张

    大婚之日,他命人当庭检查她,验明正身。婚后几日,他一边暗自宠溺,一边灭她满门。她以为他温柔缱绻,是情真爱切,却原来是血谋一场!一把火烧了王府,她发誓为父报仇,不死不休……
  • 斗罗之逆天的吞噬系统

    斗罗之逆天的吞噬系统

    主人公是如何完成系统派发的任务呢?主人公是如何建设自己呢?不如让我们去探索吧!
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 跨越友谊线

    跨越友谊线

    智商低?情商低?那只不过是人设而已!三国热搜,团宠……表白前还是个男孩子;表白后却成了醋厂老板和色狼!这还是同一个人吗?!颜控的最佳状态就是盯着一张绝色的脸看个够;身为国内养成系男团他做到了!官宣?!微博服务器怕是不要了!再说了本小姐还没在娱乐圈玩够呢!
  • 莫名修真时代

    莫名修真时代

    近日一款不知出处修真游戏突然出现席卷全球,全民修真时代莫名来临。谁主沉浮,还看今朝
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 封印战士

    封印战士

    凡塔星是一个科技与魔法同时存在的世界,在这里人类、妖怪与魔神们和谐的生活在这里,不过那些被异次元黑洞带来的怪物总是会给居民们增加不少麻烦……封印师们要做的自然就是消灭掉黑洞带来的怪物,封印异次元黑洞!
  • 重生后盯上了霸总

    重生后盯上了霸总

    重生前的沐戚榆痛恨薄初时“薄初时,我会恨你一辈子的。”重生后的沐戚榆开启了漫漫追夫之路“小时时,你只能是我一个人的。”沐戚榆霸道的宣示主权,薄初时眼神淡淡的瞥了她一眼并没有理她。“薄初时,何以解忧,唯有暴...”“恩?”“...抱抱你”上辈子沐戚榆恨薄初时虐了她三年,直到死前才看清自己的真心,猜到了真相。重生后沐戚榆先行一步,但好像一切都在悄然发生改变。(甜宠文,女追男,脾气暴躁女主×腹黑敏感伪弱男主)
  • 三国之江东霸王

    三国之江东霸王

    何为王道?就是对手不乖,从他身上碾过。何为霸道?就算乖,也得碾过。何为天道?亲,今天你该被碾了。何为帝道?你不想被碾,也不得不被碾!王道以德服人,霸道以力服人,王霸兼用,敬天治人。现代人穿越到三国小霸王孙策身上,用霸道和王道能否在这乱世之中成就帝道。敬请期待。